Commentary logo
Education

Schooling the Reformers

The American Spectator, April 30, 2008

This was just the latest defeat for school reformers. They also lost a battle in Idaho to develop a teacher performance pay plan and have seen recommendations made by an education panel in California convened by California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger almost summarily ignored...Read more

Data Errors

The American Spectator, Jan. 17, 2008
For reform-minded education researchers of all ideological stripes, No Child has not only given them the ability to fully evaluate school performance, but even get a handle on how states and school systems track student achievement. What they have learned proves the old adage that there is often little difference between lies and statistics.
Read more

The Myth of High-Stakes Testing
The American Spectator, Dec. 18, 2007
The standards struggle is as much about control over the nation's public schools as it is about learning. For reform-minded advocates, change-oriented urban school superintendents, business leaders, and a few civil rights groups such as the National Council of La Raza, exit exams advance their agenda by exposing the shoddy instruction given to children -- especially minorities and the poor -- by school districts.
Read more.

When Mayors Get Schooled

The American Spectator, Dec. 11, 2007

Driving these efforts is a realization that declining academic performance is a key reason for the flight to suburbia that has hobbled many cities. Improving the schools or offering new ones, especially so-called arts and science magnet schools, back-to-basics curricula and Montessori-style programs, will keep young, middle-class families and, in turn, spur economic growth. Competition from vouchers and charter schools, so goes the theory, will spur traditional districts to change. For school reformers and many grassroots leaders, mayoral-led reform is a chance to bypass school bureaucracies and their allies, who are unwilling to embark on much-needed fixes.
Read more. And Joanne Jacobs offers her own thoughts.

No Parent Left Behind

The American Spectator, Nov. 15, 2007
Parents seem to agree that schools are a mess. In a 2007 survey of parents by the Gallup Organization and Phi Delta Kappa, 84 percent gave public schools overall grades of C or lower; only 63 percent of parents rated the schools so woefully three years ago. But the fact 89 percent of the nation's students still attend traditional public schools suggests that most parents aren't dissatisfied with the status quo.        Read more. And check out the Education Gadfly's comments on this piece and vouchers in general.

The courts

Two Cheers for the Ninth Circuit

The American Spectator,

Of course, "as liberal" needs some context here. As the largest of the 11 Federal judicial districts, covering California, eight other Western states, and two U.S. territories, the Ninth Circuit naturally attracts attention. It has come under fire from conservatives for its rubber band-like interpretations of the Constitution and rulings that often go against the intent of Congress... Just in the last two years, Ninth Circuit appellate judges ruled against U.S. Attorney General John Ashcroft's efforts to fight California's legalization of medical marijuana and threw out the death penalty conviction of former alarm salesman John Visciotti, who allegedly teamed up with another colleague to murder and rob two of his former co-workers in order to pay off their motel bill.

Read More

 

Economic Affairs and Globalization
Made in Europe
The American Spectator, April 2, 2004
Along with McDonald's restaurants and Levis jeans, American entertainment has long been blamed by Europe's political and intellectual elites for imposing a "cretin" culture and weakening native cultures. That consumers actively seek out and enjoy Mickey Mouse and other Hollywood fare doesn't seem to register.

Neither does the reality that Hollywood recycles as many European cultural staples -- think Cinderella, Tomb Raider, and Harry Potter -- as it exports all things American. Among the top film directors are German native Roland Emmerich of Independence Day fame and British-born Anthony Minghella, whose Civil War epic, Cold Mountain, was shot in Romania.
Read More

Government Reform and Accountability
Bust Times
The American Spectator, May 24, 2004
Money management isn't the first thing that comes to mind when one thinks of San Diego. The southernmost major city in California is better-known for its beaches, naval bases, biotech firms and, for hedonists and illegal aliens, its convenient location to Tijuana and the Mexican border.

But residents of San Diego and other cities throughout the nation have come to learn the meaning "actuarial charts" and other arcane elements of the financial discipline. The hard way. Thanks to fat retirement packages for government employees handed out during the last decade's bull market, taxpayers may end up forking over billions to shore up its pensions.
-- Read More

Immigration

H-1B Education

The American Spectator, Aug. 12, 2008
You would expect high tech giants such as Microsoft, Cisco Systems, and the U.S. division of India's tech support powerhouse, Infosys, to be among the biggest users of H-1B skilled-labor visas. The same holds true for universities such as Johns Hopkins, the University of Michigan and Purdue -- the world's training ground for skilled workers and research-and-development.

But some of the largest users of H-1B visas aren't tech firms or major research universities. Rather, these unlikely users are the nation's public school systems...-- Read More

 

Politics
Do the Wright Thing

The American Spectator, May 16, 2008
Many black churches are still run by old-school pastors who came of age during the Black Power movement of the late 1960s. Their black liberation theology embraces a philosophy of black pride, and a view of American history and life, which can at times verge on separatism.

The clergymen and their older parishioners tend to harbor sentiments about homosexuality that are sometimes more philosophically conservative and less-tolerant than those expressed by some Christian fundamentalists. This despite the fact that closeted gays often make up the gospel choirs, are some of the most popular black cultural icons, sit in the pews as prominent civic leaders, even stand in the pulpit.
Read more

Waterloo on the Wabash
The American Spectator, May 8, 2008
Barack Obama should probably send thank-you notes to Congressman Andre Carson; Carson's Republican challenger Jon Elrod; Gary, Indiana mayor Rudy Clay; and white voters in Elkhart, Monroe, and Marion counties. After all, they helped to make him the presumptive Democratic presidential nominee...
Read more

Malthus' Quarreling Children

The American Spectator, March 25, 2004

But for all the rancor both sides share the same underlying theme of modern environmentalism first espoused by Malthus. This almost Hobbesian view of human existence is reflected in doomsday scenarios proposed by Lamm and others. "Unabated" immigration, they say, will cause the United States to have a population of at least 800 million by the beginning of the twenty-second century.

That in turn, will wreak an ecological havoc of "stink and sprawl" similar to conditions in China and India because the country will have to mow down national forests and other spaces, ultimately polluting our air and water.
Read More

Urban Affairs

Justice Daleyed

The American Spectator, Aug. 18, 2008
THE BLATANT SLEAZE IS as familiar to the average Chicago resident as a Carl Sandberg poem. After all, this is stomping grounds of the most legendary of American mobsters, Al Capone, who bribed every city official he could, and the spectacularly dishonest "Big Bill" Thompson, who collected three bucks from every city worker seeking a job.

Until recently, however, the quality-of-life improvements made the corruption and the ridiculous bans a lot easier to take. Since taking office, Daley fils managed to improve Chicago's stature by erasing two decades of woefully inept leadership...--
Read More

Bloom Off the Rose

The American Spectator, May 19, 2008
But the former Wall Street stock trader-turned-media billionaire [Michael Bloomberg] didn't fully learn the lessons about improving quality of life taught by Giuliani's successful tenure. As mayor he has placed more emphasis on public relations than on strong, steady management that follows up on his successes. Read more

Prince of the City

The American Spectator, Feb. 27, 2008

The younger Carson could manage to keep the seat in the family. But his struggles show the difficulty of sustaining old-style black political machines, many of which were built during the Civil Rights era on race-baiting, appeals to black pride, and the doling out of welfare benefits.
Read more

Carson's Last Stand

The American Spectator, Dec. 4, 2007

Carson expertly exploited the race card: During a 2002 re-election campaign, she stormed off the stage during a debate, accusing her Republican opponent, Brose McVey, of "racial polarization" after a series of ads, including those from the National Republican Congressional Committee, accusing her of failing to pay her property taxes on time...Read more

Guiliani's Lesson

The American Spectator, Nov. 20, 2007

Across the nation, Peterson was lauded by education reform wonks for breaking with the Democratic Party -- and its support for the public education establishment -- and becoming the only mayor in America to authorize charter schools... He also took his campaign against gory videogames to the national level this year after he became president of the National League of Cities... Those matters, however, aren't paramount on the minds of residents in urban communities, who want crime-free streets, neighborhoods free of vandalism, pothole-free streets, family-friendly parks and low taxes.

Read more. And check out L.A. Times editorialist Tim Cavanaugh's thoughts.

Free Trade

H-1B EDUCATION

The American Spectator, Aug. 11, 2008
You would expect high tech giants such as Microsoft, Cisco Systems, and the U.S. division of India's tech support powerhouse, Infosys, to be among the biggest users of H-1B skilled-labor visas. The same holds true for universities such as Johns Hopkins, the University of Michigan and Purdue -- the world's training ground for skilled workers and research-and-development.

But some of the largest users of H-1B visas aren't tech firms or major research universities. Rather, these unlikely users are the nation's public school systems... Read More

 

TRADE SCHOOL

The American Spectator, Aug. 5, 2008
The students returning this fall to Hollywood High School in Los Angeles probably know more about such Tinseltown landmarks at the Walk of Fame than about the Doha Round of trade talks that collapsed for the umpteenth time last week. Nor are they likely to know about the arguments being made by the AFL-CIO, Ralph Nader's Public Citizen, and other groups opposed to free trade, for which the stalled negotiations were the sweetest music. -- Read More